Reshaping The Business Of Law
admin@catolex.law 0121 387 4410

What is Estoppel?

Estoppel is a legal principle that prevents a person from asserting something contrary to what is implied by a previous action, statement, or established legal position. 

In so many words: it prevents a party going back on a promise you have relied upon to your detriment.

Estoppel may arise between Mr A and Mrs B, if Mr A can show:

  • Some clear and unequivocal communication from (B) as to a particular state of affairs, or a shared understanding between A and B.
  • B must have objectively intended A to rely upon that statement or promise.
  • A reasonably relied upon the communication or understanding to its detriment.
  • B now seeks to resile from the original communication or understanding.

Estoppel is aimed at preventing injustice or unfairness that might result if someone is allowed to change their position after leading others to rely on their original words or actions.

There are various types of estoppel, including:

  1. Promissory Estoppel: This prevents a party from going back on a promise made even if it’s not supported by a formal contract, especially when the other party has relied on that promise to their detriment.
  2. Proprietary Estoppel: This arises in property law when a person is stopped or prevented from asserting their strict legal rights in a property due to assurances or actions they’ve taken that led another to rely on those assurances to their detriment.

Estoppel serves to uphold fairness and prevent someone from changing their position to the detriment of another when the latter has reasonably relied on the former’s previous actions or representations.

Promissory Estoppel

In the case of Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd [1947] KB 130, the court examined the concept of promissory estoppel, a legal principle that prevents a party from going back on a promise even if it’s not supported by a formal contract.

During World War II, the landlord of a property, High Trees House Ltd, agreed to reduce the rent for Central London Property Trust Ltd due to financial difficulties. This agreement wasn’t formalized in writing. After the war ended and the property market improved, the landlord sought the original higher rent. However, the court ruled that the landlord couldn’t claim the higher rent for the period when the agreement to reduce rent was in place.

The case established the principle of promissory estoppel, indicating that if a party makes a promise and the other party relies on it, altering their position as a result, the first party cannot renege on that promise if it would be unjust or inequitable to do so. This case set a significant precedent in contract law, particularly in terms of estoppel and the enforcement of promises made without a formal contract.

Proprietary Estoppel

In Thorner v Major [2009] 1 WLR 776, the court examined the concept of proprietary estoppel and the issue of whether promises made could give rise to a claim based on this principle.

Mr. Major, the defendant, made assurances to his cousin, Mr. Thorner, promising him a piece of land and encouraging him to work on the farm with the expectation of inheriting it. 

Thorner relied on these assurances, dedicating substantial time and effort to the farm over several decades.

However, when Major passed away, his estate did not provide Thorner with the land as promised. Thorner then pursued a claim based on proprietary estoppel, asserting that he had relied on Major’s assurances to his detriment.

The court ruled in favor of Thorner, acknowledging that Major’s assurances had led Thorner to reasonably rely on the promise of inheriting the land. 

Thorner’s significant efforts and contributions to the farm, based on these promises, justified the court’s decision to enforce the promise through proprietary estoppel, granting Thorner an interest in the land.

This case established that promises or assurances, if relied upon to one’s detriment, can form the basis for a claim of proprietary estoppel, especially when substantial efforts have been made in reliance on those assurances.

Other recognised Estoppels in English Common Law

Estoppel by deed

Also known as “equitable estoppel by deed,” is a legal principle that prevents a party who has executed a deed (a written and signed legal document) from later denying the truth of statements contained within that deed.

When someone signs a deed, they are legally bound by the statements or promises made in that document. This principle applies to both the parties involved in the deed and anyone who derives their rights from that deed.

Estoppel by deed is based on the idea that by executing a deed, a person asserts the truth of the facts stated in it and cannot later deny their truthfulness if it would be unfair or unjust to do so.

For instance, if a deed conveys ownership of a property from one person to another and is properly executed, the grantor (the person transferring the property) cannot later claim they did not own the property or deny the transfer, as they’re estopped from contradicting the deed’s terms.

Contractual estoppel 

A principle often used in contractual agreements, where parties agree that certain statements or facts specified within the contract will be binding and prevent the parties from asserting the contrary in the future, even if the actual circumstances differ.

In essence, contractual estoppel allows parties to agree in a contract that they will not assert certain rights or facts that are inconsistent with the terms outlined in the agreement, even if those rights or facts might exist or be true.

For instance, in a contract, Party A might agree not to assert ownership of certain property, even if they have legal rights to it, based on the terms specified in the contract. This means that Party A is estopped from claiming ownership as per the terms of the agreement.

It’s important to note that contractual estoppel operates within the confines of the contract itself and does not override the law. Courts might enforce contractual estoppel unless it’s found to be unconscionable or contrary to public policy. Also, the effectiveness of contractual estoppel depends on the specific language and circumstances outlined in the contract.

Estoppel by judgment 

This principle says, in short, you cannot litigate the same thing twice!

It encompasses two primary forms: cause of action estoppel and issue estoppel.

  1. Cause of Action Estoppel: This arises when a particular cause of action has been litigated and determined by a court judgment. It prevents parties from re-litigating the same cause of action between the same parties or those in privity with them. Essentially, if a matter has been conclusively decided by a court, it cannot be re-opened in subsequent proceedings.
  2. Issue Estoppel: Issue estoppel, on the other hand, arises when a specific issue (or a particular point of fact or law) has been directly determined in earlier legal proceedings. This prevents parties from re-litigating the same issue in subsequent legal actions between the same parties or those in privity with them, even if the overall cause of action is different.

Both cause of action estoppel and issue estoppel serve to prevent parties from repeatedly bringing the same matter or issues before the courts, promoting finality in legal decisions and avoiding inconsistent judgments. These estoppels ensure that once a matter or issue has been judicially determined, it cannot be re-litigated between the same parties.

Waiver by estoppel refers to a situation where someone gives up or relinquishes their legal rights due to their actions, statements, or conduct, causing another party to reasonably rely on the belief that those rights have been abandoned or waived. This principle is based on the concept of estoppel, where a person is prevented from asserting a right because their prior actions or statements led someone else to rely on the assumption that the right had been waived.

For instance, if someone consistently accepts late rent payments without objection, they may be deemed to have waived their right to insist on timely payments. By creating the reasonable expectation that late payments are acceptable, they’re estopped from later demanding prompt payment.

Waiver by estoppel 

This is established by:

  1. A clear representation or conduct by one party leads the other to believe that a right has been waived.
  2. The other party reasonably relies on this representation or conduct.
  3. The first party intends or is aware that the other party will rely on this representation or conduct.
  4. The reliance on the representation or conduct results in detriment or change in position for the relying party.

This principle prevents unfairness and injustice by not allowing a party to assert a right that they have led another party to believe has been waived, especially when the other party has relied on this belief to their detriment.

This article provides general guidance only and cannot be relied upon as legal advice: expert advice should be sought in relation to particular circumstances.

    Comments are closed

    Ready to start?

    0121 387 4410 admin@catolex.law
    Birmingham Office
    Grosvenor House, 11 St Pauls Square, Birmingham,
    B3 1RB
    Northampton Office
    Beckett House
    14 Billing Road, Northampton,
    NN1 5AW
    Market Harborough Office
    5 The Point
    Rockingham Road
    Market Harborough,
    LE16 7QU
    Cato Lex is a trading name of Cato Lex Limited. Cato Lex Limited is not authorised by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Cato Lex only provides regulated legal services as a consulting company to recognised bodies, licensed bodies and recognised sole practices authorised by the SRA. Cato Lex Limited (Company Number 1142507) has its registered office at 5 The Point, Rockingham Road, Market Harborough, LE16 7QU.